DastardlyOldMan wrote:Maybe there's something else where I'm being skeezy?
You've thrown around a lot of names as suspicious. Then you vote for somebody else with less or no justification. The only players that you've said might have done something human are me and Admetus
. But you know, it's funny that you then soft-push me and vote for Admetus on the following day
Your'e right - it's my new wolf tactic to only leave people that I've already voted for alive until the end game, that way they're good and defensive.
I *did* mention that I'd like to do it, and I did - I wasn't aware that was a binding commitment).
You did the work, so why not share it? Even if it's inconclusive, maybe you save someone else that work. Maybe it makes sense later.
You and I have significantly different opinions on signal-to-noise ratio, and the amount of work to translate my textpad notes into a viable forum post wasn't worth the effort. And they were still not promises, so saying that I'm wolfy because I broke my sacred vow to bring you enlightenment is pushing it. You're definitely reaching there.
Interesting fact, though: it's a lot harder to do serious analysis in the main thread if you're putting a lot of work into the wolf forum. Just saying.
There's the fixation again. You've already decided, and now you're slanting things toward the outcome that you've decided. Objectivity for the win. This didn't contribute in any way to your argument.
So, I know that there's at least one wolf in HH, Rictus, and Admetus.
Only one wolf other than JRS. JRS is the alpha. Sphenodont called him the Alpha and JRS did not deny it. If your list has 2 wolves, we already lose via parity (5 players, 3 wolves).
This seems like it would be a fairly safe assumption, doesn't it?
For everyone that wants to vote on me, I'd love to hear your reasoning on the other two players.
Why? Do your own damn work. I'd like to see any plausible scenario where I'm a wolf. That would be amusing as hell. Maybe we'll see a vote with a genuine justification behind it!
Of course - apologies for asking people to share what information they had. Since you've already decided that I'm a wolf, do you mind if the rest of us participate normally?
EVERYONE has plausible scenarios where they're a wolf, and EVERYONE has a valid argument for why they're not. The fact is that you're choosing to believe or interpret some of those in different ways. This is why I'm flailing with my votes.
Hellheart: HORRIBLE vote pattern at the end of Day 2. Every time I read it, I frikkin' itch all over. Cleared by the seer, in what I believe is a pretty definitive manner. Last vote on JRS, which was a foregone conclusion at the time he made it. Several times left his own name colored red on the vote charts (probably because of strikeout defaults, but *sometimes* they're changed).
There was a possibility that he could be a witch, but given that his role was male...it would have been odd. So I assumed he was human.
Outlined his thought process on why he assumed dfer was human, expects us to make that same assumption in reverse and considers that a claim (I think?). (also, in dead seriousness
: fuck you for metagaming / attempting to metagame).
Rictus: Probably my best human read without resorting to metagame. Helped push on sphenodont on Day 2. Almost-too-early vote on JRS, and I really believe there's a wolf somewhere on JRS (well, of course I really do now, but at the time that I saw it, I also believed that). Voted off of sphenodont on Day 4. Human-y tone reads.
Admetus: Voted off of sphenodont on Day 2, extremely late to the JRS train, but early vote on sphenodont on Day 4. No real tone reads.
So, my checklist looks like:
Did something interesting Day 1: not really any of you
On the JRS train (all three of you).
On sphenodont Day 2 (Rictus only)
On sphenodont Day 4 (All But Rictus).
On rekard Day 5 (from a wolf perspective, rekard would've been human, so this doesn't say much): All but HH.
Anyhow, I wish it was as cut-and-dry as Hellheart's horse-blinders.
Hm. I've been working on this post off and on for like, 7 hours now.
I'll go with
#Vote for: Admetus