Hellheart wrote:Ozymandias wrote:Hellheart wrote:If ICB is a wolf then why doesn't that vote come from another wolf so ICB can lose some heat?
Because, as I said, I believe Wolf ICB voting for Human stigmata would take away heat from him.
Ohhhh, I see, because voting to kill humans is a great way to get human credibility!
It is when that Human is suspected to be a Wolf that you sniped to protect.
Hellheart wrote:If ICB is a wolf, there are two scenarios. One where Stigmata is human, and one where Stigmata is a wolf:
1) Wolf-ICB, instead of voting elsewhere and having the other wolves get human-Stigmata lynched, voted for human-Stigmata himself in a way that drew a lot of attention from the more analytical players. This somehow brings heat off of him.
2) Wolf-ICB, who knows that wolf-Stigmata is getting a lot of heat and is likely to be lynched, votes for wolf-Stigmata because his Day 1 vote is going to look wolfy as hell once Stigmata is revealed and he needs to give himself some wiggle room.
Out of these two scenarios, which one is more plausible? This has been the crux of my entire argument from the start and you've been dancing around it.
My argument has nothing to do with whether Human-stigmata or Wolf-stigmata is more likely in reality, so scenario (2) is irrelevant to this discussion.
I am simply arguing that Wolf-ICB would have plenty of reason to vote for Human-stigmata. Nothing you have said has made me think otherwise.